Recently, a case has come to light that has generated great controversy: an undercover police officer had relationships with at least eight independence supporters while operating in his investigative capacity. These types of practices reignite the debate about the limits of police action and to what extent the obtaining of evidence through the provocation of situations that, otherwise, might never have occurred can be considered legitimate.
What is entrapment?
The entrapment is a legal concept that has generated intense debates in the field of criminal law. It involves a situation where an agent of the State Security Forces or a third party induces a person to commit a crime that they would not have perpetrated otherwise. This mechanism has been especially controversial in the context of drug trafficking and crimes against public health.
Why is entrapment problematic?
In these cases, the action of police forces or their collaborators can result in a legal trap for the accused, which generates nullity of the procedure and, in many cases, acquittal. This problem is especially relevant in drug trafficking crimes, where the presence of undercover agents and provocateurs is a constant in the l
Do you need an expert drug trafficking attorney?
How does the role of the agent provocateur affect the theory of entrapment?
The entrapment occurs when an individual commits a criminal offense as a direct result of incitement by an agent provocateur. It is not a voluntary act, but conduct artificially generated by a police authority or a collaborator of the security forces.
For entrapment to exist, certain elements must be present:
- The initiative for the crime comes from the agent provocateur. Police action is not limited to observing or documenting an existing crime, but actively creates the criminal situation.
- The accused had no prior predisposition to commit the crime. There are no antecedents or indications that the person was involved in criminal activities before the agent’s intervention.
- The agent’s intervention was decisive. Without their incitement, the crime would never have been committed.
In these cases, police action is unlawful and contrary to the principle of minimum intervention in Criminal Law, since a crime is being manufactured instead of investigated.
Example of entrapment in drug trafficking
One of the areas where entrapment most occurs is in drug trafficking cases. An agent provocateur can incite an individual to broker a drug sale, suggesting they get involved in the operation when, otherwise, they would never have had the intention to do so.
If
Do you need an attorney specializing in crimes against public health?
How can a defense attorney help you if you’ve been charged with drug trafficking?
If you have been charged with drug trafficking and suspect that an agent provocateur participated in your case, having a criminal defense attorney expert in crimes against public health is essential.
The defense attorney will analyze the legality of police intervention and determine if fundamental rights have been violated
A drug trafficking expert attorney can analyze whether police action has violated your rights and, if applicable, propose a defense strategy based on Supreme Court doctrine.
To ensure the best possible defense, a criminal attorney specialized in drug trafficking can:
- Analyze the origin of the investigation. If the procedure began with the action of an agent provocateur, it may be grounds for nullity.
- Challenge evidence obtained unlawfully. Evidence obtained through police provocation cannot be used in trial.
- Demonstrate that the accused had no predisposition. If the initiative for the crime came from the agent provocateur and not from the accused, the defense can argue that the infraction would never have occurred without that incitement.
- Request case dismissal or acquittal. When police action is illegal, the only possible consequence is nullity of the case.
Abogado penalista en Madrid (Graduado en Derecho y ADE con Máster de Acceso a la Abogacía), experto en procedimientos complejos y técnicos en Derecho Penal. Cuenta con títulos como el Curso de DerechoPenal Avanzado impartido por magistrados del Tribunal Supremo en el Iltre. Colegio de Abogacía de Madrid.